John Dewey: The Origins of Experiential Learning
American philosopher John Dewey (1859-1952), the founding theorist of experiential learning, posits it as a salutary corrective to the limitations of traditional education, which he characterizes in Experience and Education (1938) as a passive student receiving from a teacher preformulated ideas from the past—frequently with little connection to the student’s own life, to the present moment, or to other ideas in the curriculum—and committing them to memory. (Theorist Paolo Freire later terms this the Banking Model of education.) In place of this model of learning, Dewey proposes that students learn best through active engagement with the very things they are studying. While Dewey’s vision for experiential learning is expansive (and inspiring – Experience and Education is a bracing read), these three tenets constitute a good starting point for bringing his vision to life:
Begin with the students in front of you.
Who are they, what do they care about, and what do they already know about the subject at hand? It is the instructors’ responsibility not just to be experts in their discipline; they must connect content knowledge to the students sitting before them. Both the internal world of the student and the external world as made manifest in disciplinary knowledge must be in conversation for students to learn.
Students are active, not passive, and creative, not merely receptive, in their pursuit of learning.
For Dewey, learning is not about mastering a predetermined curriculum or canon, but about acquiring the ability to think critically and tackle challenges that arise in the course of an experience. Students learn as they work through difficulties. This feature of experiential learning connects it to the broader tradition of constructivism, a discovery-oriented approach to education whereby students’ build their own knowledge of the world, rather than having the knowledge presented to them by an instructor or a textbook.
Students learn by moving between experience and reflection.
While experiences are necessary for learning, on their own they are not sufficient. Experience must be followed by reflection. Instructors must create meaningful opportunities for students to review what they have experienced, pulling out the moments that confirm their prior knowledge as well as those that challenge what they thought they knew. Through this process of analysis, revision, synthesis, and ongoing experimentation, students learn.
It is not enough that certain materials and methods have proved effective with other individuals at other times. There must be a reason for thinking that they will function … with particular individuals at a particular time. (Dewey 46).
the educator cannot start with knowledge already organized and proceed to ladle it out in doses. (Dewey 83)
To reflect is to look back over what has been done so as to extract the net meanings which are the capital stock for intelligent dealing with future experiences. (Dewey 87)
Explore an example of the Kolb Learning Cycle as experienced by a hypothetical college student learning Spanish in Quito, Ecuador:
Roberta, a student newly arrived in Quito, Ecuador, is nervous about the appropriate times to use the formal “usted” form of address rather than the informal “tú” (both of which are translated as “you” in English). During the student’s first week living with an Ecuadorian family and attending classes, Roberta hears the informal “tú” used exclusively in her homestay between parents and children, and her host parents encourage her to use “tú” with them, as well. However, when students speak to their professors at the university, they use the formal, or “usted”.
When Roberta has a drink with other American students later in the week, they begin to talk about the intricacies of “tú” vs. “usted” together, relating what they’ve experienced in different social contexts.
They come to a consensus about how the formal vs informal mode of address works in Ecuador: “tú” is for people with whom you are on a first-name basis, and “usted” is for those whom you address by last name.
They try this out for a few weeks and it seems to hold true.
A month later, a young couple visits Roberta’s homestay family with their baby, and she hears her host parents using “usted” when they pick up the baby and talk babytalk to him.
Roberta wonders why and asks her friends what they think, and the learning cycle has begun again.